55: The Disappearance of Susan Walsh (S5 EP 2...

A woman disappears after a car accident; a double allegedly served Nazi Rudolf Hess' jail term; Virginia woman's brutal murder. This Week’s Sponsors: Lumi - Go to lumigummies.com and use code ITHINKNOT for 30% off your order SKIMS - Shop your favorite bras and underwear at skims. ...  Show more

This week while Ellyn is on a short vacation, Joey is joined by podcaster and friend of the show, Rebecca Lavoie (Crime Writers On, These Are Their Stories, and Something’s Off on YouTube). They discuss Alex Murdaugh’s conviction being overturned, then they cover Kouri Richins' s ...  Show more

In late 1994, Susan Smith became one of the most hated women in the world. The case of her two missing young sons hit the national news after Susan told police that an African-American male had kicked her out of her car and taken off with it while her kids were still inside. ...

Oscar-winning actress and humanitarian Susan Sarandon explains why she credits her success to the fact that all of her plans failed. A New Jersey native and the eldest of nine siblings, Susan grew up in a strict Roman Catholic school system, which she says shaped her world view i ...  Show more

After a woman’s body is found floating down the peaceful Brandywine River in Wilmington, Delaware, she is eventually identified as Susan Ledyard, a brilliant and beloved high school English teacher. At first, her family believes Susan’s death was a tragic accident, then months la ...  Show more

Susan Gelles was a lawyer in her 30s who was too busy to find love. But after finally admitting that she was lonely, Susan did something that went against all her best instincts. She started attending singles mixers.

On this episode, Susan shares her disastrous mismatche ...