5 Scary & Creepy Small Town Murder Mysteries

5 Scary & Creepy Small Town Murder Mysteries

Up next

STRANGE & SCARY Mysteries of The Month - March 2026

Welcome everybody to the strange and scary mysteries of the month where we find the creepiest true crime stories from all around the world currently going down and lay them out here for you to check out. Thanks so much for tuning in today, here are the Strange and Scary mysteries ...  Show more

UNSOLVED, COVERED UP & ICE COLD: 5 Real MURDERS That Happened in Broad Daylight

Daylight is supposed to be when we feel safe because everything is out in the open. But in these stories today, people stepped into their ordinary day and straight into someone else’s sinister plan. Welcome to Scary Mysteries and thanks for tuning in. This is Killed or Vanished i ...  Show more

Recommended Episodes

S2 E15: The Teenage Cult-Group That Nearly Got away with Murder: The Disciples of Destruction
Behind You

Mount Vernon New Hampshire is a small quiet town with population 2,000 and described as the “perfect place to live”. It has low-crime rates, great schools, beautiful scenery and friendly neighbors. It was a peaceful place where most people go to raise children and retire. But all ...  Show more

Samuel Little - The Killer of Women /// Part 1 /// 585
True Crime Garage

Samuel Little - The Killer of Women /// Part 1 /// 585

Part 1 of 3

www.TrueCrimeGarage.com

Bundy, Gacy, and the Green River Killer. All topping the list of some of the most prolific serial killers ...

  Show more

The Cheshire Murders
True Crime All The Time

Bill Petit and his wife Jennifer Hawke-Petit had built a wonderful life. They lived in the upscale neighborhood of Cheshire, Connecticut with their two amazing daughters 17-year-old Hayley and 11-year-old Michaela. In 2007, Jennifer and Michaela were at the grocery when they c ...

  Show more

Hell and Gone Murder Line: Shirley Reine
Hell and Gone

It was May 10, 2005 when police in the tiny town of Falmouth, Massachusetts, a sleepy picturesque little town on Cape Cod, got a horrifying phone call. Fifty-one-year-old Shirley Reine had been found, slumped on the garage floor, hanging out of her Nissan Maxima in a pool of b ...

  Show more