Reasonable Doubt (Part One)

Kirby Carpenter was a wealthy Mississippi businessman and modern-day renaissance man. In 2022, he vanished without warning, leaving behind his girlfriend, Caitlin Spence, and their infant daughter. Two days later, a disturbing discovery behind their home would change everything… ...  Show more

Just after midnight on June 22nd, 2019, a disturbing 911 call was made by two children, who reported that they had just been stabbed in their home. As police arrived on scene, they made two horrific discoveries. One was the dead body of 62-year-old Diane Madison, grandmother of t ...  Show more

*this case involves discussion of suicide* https://linktr.ee/murderwithmyhusband On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the murder-suicide of mom and daughter, Pam and Helen Hargan. But was it really? Case Sources: Nbcwashington.com, “Police: Daughter Kills Mom, S ...  Show more

Sean Lannon says he murdered 16 people, including his ex-wife and a former mentor who allegedly sexually abused him as a child. Lannon allegedly enticed four of the victims to a residence in New Mexico before killing and dismembering two of them. Authorities have tied Lannon t ...

Throughout his life, Drew Peterson was known as a womanizer, a fact that would eventually lead to the divorce from his third wife, Kathleen Savio, after his affair with 17-year-old Stacy Cales came to light. During Drew and Kathleen’s tumultuous divorce, and coincidentally right ...  Show more

Today we'll hear evidence that Girl X allegedly had a 'hit list' of five children she wanted to kill.We'll hear how messages exchanged between the two teenagers accused of Brianna's murder show Boy Y was reluctant to do it on a school night because he wanted to revise.And we'll h ...  Show more