Tara Calico

22-year-old Franchesca Alvarado, a devoted single mother, went on what was supposed to be a one-night trip to Atlantic City in March 2012. She never returned. Over a year later, parts of her remains washed up on the beach. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Franchesca Alvarado. ...  Show more

Justin Gaines, an 18-year-old college freshman, vanished after a night out at a Georgia nightclub in November 2007. Despite years of investigations, tips, searches, and alleged confessions, Justin has never been found.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Justi ...  Show more

When Tara Calico mysteriously vanished in 1988, suspected to be the victim of foul play, her case may have gotten lost with the countless other missing person cases in the US, were it not for the discovery of an alarming Polaroid photo in a parking lot 1500 miles away.

...

Tara was stalked by her abusive ex-boyfriend. While online dating, Tara formed a quick friendship with a man she met. He needed a place to stay, so she offered him a spare room in her house, leading to a romantic relationship. Shortly after moving in together, he became abusiv ...

On a crisp fall day in October of 1991, Patricia Scoville set out for a bike ride on the scenic Moss Glen Falls trails in Stowe, Vermont. When she hadn’t returned home more than two days later, Patty’s roommate reported her missing, triggering a search and rescue effort that s ...

Tara Costigan was murdered in 2015, one day after taking out a DVO on her ex-partner Marcus Rappel. The day he laid a finger on her was the day he murdered her. Before that the abuse had been verbal. Emotional.  Tara did everything ‘right’. She followed advice and took steps in t ...  Show more