Portrait of Terror: The Creepy True Story of ...

For centuries, hikers and travelers have seen strange beings at the top of the Santa Lucia Mountains.Witnesses describe them the same way: tall men, wearing capes or cloaks, with a walking stick by its side, and wide a wide-brimmed hat. In fact, the Spanish colonizers also saw th ...  Show more

This is a lesser-known, short eerie legend of Ketell, as found on Chronicon Anglicanum by Radulphi de Coggeshall. You might recognize the chronicle's name because it's the same one where the story of the Green Children of Woolpit appears.In this story, an innocent teenager that w ...  Show more

In this true scary story, our storyteller explains his terrifying experience as he witnesses apparitions. The story takes a turn when it begins to affect his mental and emotional health, something that is unfortunately not uncommon for those who have experienced supernatural even ...  Show more

In this episode, Payton unravels one of the internet’s strangest mysteries — a supposedly cursed painting rumored to have claimed lives. Links: NEW MERCH LINK: https://mwmhshop.com Twitch: twitch.tv/throatypie Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/intothedarkpod/ Discount Codes: h ...  Show more

In this true scary story, Sage tells us about her experience with her family arriving at a haunted AirBnB. To this day, she still wonders who or what was lurking around the house.

Listen to more shows over at Scary.fm or try ad-free episodes at ScaryPlus.com

  Show more

"It Came From the Mirror" In our first creepy account, Diana tells us about her family's experiences living on a property in Mexico that used to be a cemetery. From the story of a little boy that stares from the corner of the room, to unexplained sounds.  "First Time in New Orlea ...  Show more