346: Carnegie Deli Murders

Cari Farver vanished without a trace in 2012, but what followed was a years-long digital nightmare that left friends, family, and investigators questioning everything they thought they knew. After her disappearance, texts and messages began pouring in from Cari’s accounts, angry, ...  Show more

November 7th, 2025, 18-year-old Anna Marie Kepner was found dead under a bed aboard the Carnival Horizon naked and covered in life jackets. But while investigators tried to figure out what happened in that cabin, the deeper question was already forming: How did every adult in her ...  Show more

<div>On September 25, 2007, 22-year-old Amy Winnick left her job near Calabasas, California, and headed home. Her cell phone rang. It was was her 25-year-old brother Jesse. "Don't go home," he told her. And then he said "I just killed Mom," and then he hung up. This unimaginable ...  Show more

<h3>The first ep this week sees the wonderful writer and comedian, Jessica Knappett join the force to divulge the time she had the most authentic American experience possible, while also helping to solve a crime which leaves Taylor and Hannah feeling all at sea.</h3><h3>And to fi ...  Show more

I Think My Father Helped Kidnap a Woman in the 1980s; 'Dr Death' Harold Shipman Came into My House!; The Day I Accidentally Stopped My Kidnapping?; My Brush with Moorish Sovereign Citizens; Some Hope for Wildfire Survivors from a Survivor; and (Almost) Real Death at a Fake Murder ...  Show more

We continue our cross analysis of the HBO Max scripted version of "The Staircase" starring Toni Collette, and how it stacks up to the true events in the death of Kathleen Peterson. Laura and Jim both question the 911 calls made by Michael Peterson compared to how it was depict ...