Abducted While Biking Home: The Murder of 20-...

In November 2018, Carla Stefaniak travelled to Costa Rica to celebrate her birthday with family. After extending her trip by one night, Carla was last heard from after dropping her sister-in-law at San José Airport. But when she failed to board her flight home the following morni ...  Show more

On February 16th, 2026, 37-year-old Ashley Flynn was found shot to death inside her home in Tipp City, Ohio, after her husband called 911 to report that an intruder had broken in while their children slept. As first responders arrived at the scene, questions quickly began to emer ...  Show more

A beautiful young woman's brutal murder at the height of Midwestern summer shatters her community's sense of safety forever and exposes a monster hiding right there in plain sight. 

Please join us in supporting justiceforsierah.org ...

In this episode, Payton and Garrett explore the chilling case of Sierah Joughin. When she fails to return home after a bike ride, her family and friends fear the worst. As concern grows, the police launch an investigation, retracing her steps from that fateful evening. NEW YOUTU ...  Show more

As Mickey Shunick was biking home one night in Lafayette, little did she know a car was gliding slowly after her, like a shark waiting for the right moment to seize and attack its prey. Sierra Joughin, she too was biking home through corn fields, when a man saw her go past, he lu ...  Show more

A 12-year-old girl left home to take a bike ride. Only her bike was found later that day. Days later, the unthinkable was discovered. It became a race against time to get a predator off the street before he struck again.

For episode information and photos, please visit < ...