Big Muddy Monster

In this fifty-sixth installment of fictional horror written and narrated by Dan Cummins, we meet young Sophie Bennet, who has been hired by a couple to baby sit their two children, Callum and Eilidh, for a few hours on a Wednesday night. They live outside of a small Scottish town ...  Show more

We spend all of our time with Dan in Hawaii this week! We head to the Big Island today for five stories. Dan's first story is about something creepy that happened in Hilo in 1902 and 1903 primarily. It revolves around the ghost of a murdered man. Then his second is really a colle ...  Show more

Stories in this episode:- Having a Drink with a Dead Man, by Leti - David's Shadow, by Rachel- My Abduction Story, by emodrakefan- 200 Year Old Haunted Farmhouse, by ctenc001- The Red Light, by Tanu - My Stories, by AshleyBe sure to check out Shelby Scott's podcast at scareyoutos ...  Show more

Well, this episode might be haunted. Our video recording mysteriously stopped midway through, leaving us wondering if our new studio guest (a creepy thrift-store clown) had something to do with it. Whatever the cause, this episode is filled with eerie encounters, wild cryptid sig ...  Show more

Episode 315 - The Vampire Epidemic of Medveđa: A True Horror Story What if we told you that one of the most terrifying vampire stories ever… is actually documented in government records? 😱 In this episode, we unearth the chilling legend of Arnold Paole, a Serbian soldier whose ...  Show more

Dan and Lyndze Cummins, hosts of Scared to Death join us today to share some creepy tales. First, we chat about their personal thoughts on and experiences with the other side before they bring us to California and Idaho for some very strange stories filled with legends, curses an ...  Show more