Our Favorite Guilty Pleasure Horror Movies (Halloween 2025)

Our Favorite Guilty Pleasure Horror Movies (H...

Up next

Episode 8: "Down at the Crossroads"

America’s first settlers were afraid of a lot of things and when they were afraid of something they reflexively connected it to the Devil – whether it was places like forests and woods or people, like the Native Americans who had predated their arrival on these shores by hundreds ...  Show more

Episode 7: "In the Pines"

The Puritans and the early colonists found more monsters in America than just witches. The Devil had birthed a variety of what were often called “monstrous births” and they became signs and omens for the believers in an angry god. Spectral, shape-shifting dogs, along with demonic ...  Show more

Recommended Episodes

100. Real Life "Purge": Killers Inspired by Horror Movies
Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries

In 2016, Jonathan Cruz went on a four day killing spree inspired by the movie "The Purge". In 1985, Mark Branch wanted to live out his fantasy of being Jason from Friday the 13th. What causes some people to be inspired by horror movies to commit horrible acts of violence? TW: Su ...  Show more

5 REAL Murder Cases More Twisted Than Horror Movies
Scary Mysteries

These aren’t just killers—they are people who wanted to leave their mark in ways that are hard to fathom. Whether out of obsession, revenge or just cause they felt like it, The individuals you’re about to hear about left behind crime scenes that aren’t typical for true crime tale ...  Show more

FULL SHOW: Jeff’s Big Pumpkin Parody, Rank Me Date + Scariest Haunted House EVER (10/17/25)
Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

We're trying out a new idea for our fans of the 2nd Date Update! Every Sunday, we will be hosting one of our FULL HOUR episodes from our main show feed, Brooke & Jeffrey! We'd love to hear your feedback...but please send all negative reviews to Jeffrey. FULL SHOW: Friday, October ...  Show more

322: National Park After Dark X Heart Starts Pounding
National Park After Dark

<div>In today’s long awaited collaboration, we team up with Kaelyn Moore of the podcast Heart Starts Pounding. Kaelyn covers all sorts of creepy, strange and unexplainable topics from around the world on her show, but today we all dive into the Reddit world (which is scary in and ...  Show more