The Farmville Murders

On October 30, 1975, fifteen-year-old Martha Moxley failed to return home after a night out with friends in Belle Haven, an exclusive wealthy enclave in Greenwich, CT. The following morning, Moxley’s badly beaten body was discovered underneath a tree, just a few hundred feet from ...  Show more

WEIRDOS!! For this month's BONUS EPISODE, Ash & Alaina dive fang-first into Breaking Dawn: Part 1. Share in the trauma of the ATROCIOUS Cullen wigs, the weird internalized misogyny of vampire reproduction, and the fact that Jacob imprints on a child with a name that sounds suspic ...  Show more

In 2009 in Farmville, Virginia, 16-year-old Emma Niederbrock struck up an online relationship with an aspiring rapper. The two bonded over their love of music, but Emma didn’t realize that her online boyfriend was a much different person in real life. How to support:For extra per ...  Show more

For our first episode, we look at a quadruple murder in the small town of Sarah, Mississippi.

A young, rural Mississippi man does the unthinkable, and pays the ultimate price. Along the way, we learn that kerosene can fuel a town, and to never trust a guy who keeps a mo ...

“To feel like at any moment something tragic could happen put me in a deep, deep cloud as far as who I am, what can I be, and what could I have been.”

Today’s guest requested to remain anonymous. But if you’d like to reach out to him, you can email at

“I had total grief and sadness and fear and also just disbelief that it happened. But it’s different when you lose somebody who hurt you.”

Producer: Whit Missildine

Episode Summary: After surviving a family br ...