That's So Criminal

That's So Criminal

Release Date

All Episodes

Finding Nancy Guthrie: Reading Between the Lines

Six months after Nancy Guthrie vanished from her Tucson home, the full text of two ransom notes is finally public, and the details don't match. Lynden Blake breaks down the shift in tone between the notes, a mention of a smart watch investigators hadn't confirmed yet, and why Sav ...  Show more

TikTok Murder Suicide

Days before her death, TikTok influencer Sara Duffey posted a viral video calling her husband out as a pedophile. She didn’t know it would be one of the last things she ever did. Lynden Blake traces the jurisdiction dispute over Shawn Duffey's crimes, the protective order Sara fi ...  Show more

Can Twiggs be Charged? David Gelman Weighs In

Lance Twiggs may have immunity for what he's said, but that doesn't put every question about him to rest. Lynden Blake talks with former prosecutor David Gelman to unpack exactly what that immunity means, whether an accessory charge could still be on the table, and how well Twigg ...  Show more

Ohio House of Horrors

Deputies in rural Ohio serving a routine warrant found something no one expected: sixteen children who’d been living in a twelve-by-twelve-foot room for four years. In this episode, Lynden Blake breaks down the discovery of the Ohio “House of Horrors" and the four adults now faci ...  Show more

Amber's Lasting Lifeline

Thirty years ago, a nine-year-old girl rode her pink bike into a parking lot. Eight minutes later, she was gone. Her kidnapping was never solved, but it led to something that's since saved over 1,300 children: the AMBER Alert. This week, Lynden Blake traces Amber Hagerman's story ...  Show more